| Gas Station | Regular | Plus | Premium | Diesel |
 | Sunoco
19 Mills Road, Hume, NY 14745
Get Directions | $2.159 | $2.279 | $2.329 | N/A |
 | Unbranded
10 W Main St, Fillmore, NY 14735
Get Directions | $2.169 | $2.399 | $2.579 | $2.579 |
| Unbranded
44 S Genesee St, Fillmore, NY 14735
Get Directions | $2.169 | $2.399 | $2.479 | $2.679 |
 | Citgo
6963 Fillmore Rd, Portageville, NY 14536
Get Directions | $2.199 | $2.549 | $2.749 | N/A |
| Unbranded
8 S Main St, Belfast, NY 14711
Get Directions | $2.179 | $2.459 | N/A | $2.559 |
 | Valero
7959 Rte 19, Belfast, NY 14711
Get Directions | $2.179 | $2.359 | $2.459 | $3.099 |
| Valero
11595 Route 98, Freedom, NY 14065
Get Directions | $2.099 | $2.599 | $2.349 | $2.359 |
| Valero
146 E Main St, Angelica, NY 14709
Get Directions | $2.199 | N/A | N/A | $2.459 |
| Arrow Mart
131 S Main St, Castile, NY 14427
Get Directions | $2.099 | $2.299 | $2.599 | $2.499 |
| Sunoco
63 S Main St, Castile, NY 14427
Get Directions | $2.099 | $2.149
Lowest Price | $2.249 | $2.409 |
| Valero
61 Cummings Ave, Silver Springs, NY 14550
Get Directions | $2.149 | N/A | $2.909 | $2.399 |
| Arrow Mart
9924 Route 408, Dalton, NY 14836
Get Directions | $2.129 | $2.409 | $2.659 | $2.329
Lowest Price |
| Kwik Fill
427 N Main St, Warsaw, NY 14569
Get Directions | $2.059
Lowest Price | $2.159 | $2.159
Lowest Price | N/A |
 | 7-Eleven
64 S Main St, Warsaw, NY 14569
Get Directions | $2.059 | $2.259 | $2.559 | $2.379 |
| Crosbys
469 Main St, Arcade, NY 14009
Get Directions | $2.099 | $2.379 | $2.479 | $2.359 |
| Kwik Fill
582 Main St, Arcade, NY 14009
Get Directions | $2.099 | $2.199 | N/A | $2.359 |
| Noco
472 Main St, Arcade, NY 14009
Get Directions | $2.099 | $2.299 | $2.599 | $2.359 |
| Tops
658 Main St, Arcade, NY 14009
Get Directions | $2.099 | $2.299 | $2.469 | N/A |
| Crosbys
5255 Route 19 N, Belmont, NY 14813
Get Directions | $2.199 | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Citgo
78 Greenwich St, Belmont, NY 14813
Get Directions | $2.219 | N/A | N/A | N/A |